The Five Underrated Sci-Fi Movie Masterpieces

Watch the full list: The Underrated Sci-Fi Masterpieces

After seeing 300 or so films a year, I’ve learned quite a few things about the moviegoing experience: Popcorn on an empty stomach is bad news, the majority of movies released each year are formulaic drivel – a waste of time even when seen for free – and the only thing sadder than seeing incoherence rewarded at the box office is witnessing something truly brilliant trail off into utter obscurity.

It’s the forgotten (and ignored) greats that break my heart.

Over the last two months, we’ve set out on a mission to bring five underrated and unappreciated science-fiction masterpieces back from the shadows. To give them a second life on DVD. The task has been hard (see the first days of the debate here, and the 20 finalists here), but fun, and it’s led me to add some 40 films back into my Netflix queue, eager to take a second glance. Over the holidays, it was Silent Running and Predator that unleashed debates in my family’s Wisconsin living room, during my impromptu underrated film festival. Dad thought Silent Running was a treehugging disaster. There was much debate as to whether or not Predator counted as sci-fi. (We also argued plenty about my top 10 sci-fi films of the decade, as well as Tracey’s top 10 video games of the decade and Lev’s favorite sci-fi characters)

Needless to say, this project has left me conflicted. Why is it that so many smart movies fail to gain traction? How can stories of substance wither on the vine while fluff rakes in a windfall? How many other brilliant films from past generations have been lost due to a lack of distribution and ticket sales? If an epic plays to an empty theater, what’s the point?

According to Techland readers, Techland staffers and my own personal biases, here they are: The five most underrated sci-fi masterpieces.

Watch the full list: The Underrated Sci-Fi Masterpieces

60 comments
incrush
incrush

I haven't seen Primer, but the other 4 on the list are excellent choice. I know it wasn't well received, but I am a super fan of the movie "Southland Tales." Fluid Karma was a really interesting idea, and I was forced to reevaluate my opinion of professional wrestlers making the leap to acting.

moderateGuy
moderateGuy

Definitely missing from the top 5: Outland. One of a very few hollywoodsta movies that get's just about all the science right.

Contemplative_Girl
Contemplative_Girl like.author.displayName 1 Like

I haven't read all of the comments, but I agree with quite a few of the suggestions I've read, particularly Sunshine, Cube and eXistenz.

I also have to mention Dreamscape--it was the 80's version of Inception, and far more awesome, as far as I'm concerned. Also, The 13th Floor. Personally, I think the Matrix and eXistenz are better films that relate a similar story, but this one is little known and quite good.

TravisBickle
TravisBickle

@Contemplative_Girl  

Good calls, C_Girl!

The Thirteenth Floor, The Matrix and eXistenZ (all 1999) seem to make the perfect trifecta for alternative realities.

Add Dark City (1998), and the everything-you-know-is-wrong cycle is complete.

Interesting to note how they all came out about the same time.  Now there's zeitgeist for you!


And yes - The Thirteen Floor, though not great with a capital G, it's nevertheless an underrated little gem in its own right.

AmyPike
AmyPike

Okay, anyone else remember a lovely gem of a movie with an ending that will blow you away, called "The Quiet Earth"? That one should definitely have made the list!

abubasim
abubasim

Only Silent Running missing in my collection. Downloading it now from iTunes.

gaplangley
gaplangley like.author.displayName 1 Like

Oh, and does anyone else remember A Boy And His Dog (with Don Johnson)? Quirky but real science fiction amongst all of the other "post-apo" movies out at the time.

gaplangley
gaplangley

A few others for consideration:

A Scanner Darkly

Cube

π (Pi)

The Black Hole (Yes, the Disney one!)

The Brother From Another Planet

All of these exemplify what Science Fiction is all about - how science (in any form) affects us as humanity, and not just some western/cops and robbers/action hero flick set in space...

Now, if I could just get my hands on Liquid Sky, would see if that fits the bill too.

TravisBickle
TravisBickle

WHAT?!  NO MENTION OF THX 1138?!

So prescient for 1971 – you can't watch it and not be startled by just how true so much of it is today.

Televised 3D porn and beatings-for-amusement, a drug-controlled society, the debasement and devaluation of individual life for corporate gain, capitalism as religion (and vice versa), drone cops, hyper-surveillence and the elimination of privacy – it's all there.

 Yes - antiseptic and carefully paced.

 But definitely superior sci-fi.


If you want some great stupid underrated fun - check out:

  • The Hidden
  • The Fly (Cronenberg remake)
  • The Thing (Carpenter remake)
  • Five Million Years To Earth (aka Quatermass and The Pit)
  • Village Of The Damned (A true classic)
  • eXistenz  (Not to be confused with ExtenZe - the crappy male enhancement drug)


TravisBickle
TravisBickle

Clarifications:

 That's eXistenZ.

And the original 1960 version of Village Of The Damned.

teleny
teleny

Quintet, Robert Altman. A quirky Seventies film with a playable game at its heart, and a frost - covered Fuller dome as a location. Incredible, hypnotic, and timeless.

danabree43
danabree43

Outland  1981 with Sean Connery. Gritty galactic mining with Sean as the Lawman sent to keep order. Great outside  in space physical fight. Frances Sternhagen is fab here. Love the sound of this film and the tension keeps building

slickaway
slickaway

Equilibrium
Galaxy Quest
Akira
Event Horizon
Children of Men
Southland Tales
Soylent Green
Damnation Alley

elaineret
elaineret

Smilla's Sense of Snow is a great movie. Not overtly Sci-Fi until the end. Really good mystery, too.

nicholasantons
nicholasantons like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

I think Existenz is one of my favorite all time sci-fi movies that is not on this list. That movie keeps you guessing long after it's over. 

SueLange
SueLange

So the science in Primer is plausible, eh? Does that mean people are now traveling back and forth. 'Cuz, you know if it's possible, it's happening. If you build it they will come. Thanks for including Silent Running. If you don't get a lump in your throat at the end of that one, you're not alive.

J.r.Cortez
J.r.Cortez

You didn't mention Steven Spielberg's "A.I." Wayyyyy underrated, some would even say hated. This and The Fountain, both masterpieces.

malamule
malamule

I love all 5 movies listed, as well at The fountain.   I even bought the Fountain soundtrack since I had enjoyed the movie so much.

The comments here also mention movies that should make the list that I agree with:  Sunshine and Moon.

I think two movies that are missing from consideration are Code 46 and Pandorum.

And finally, how can any list be complete without the 1985 sleeper, The Quiet Earth?  

RogMat
RogMat

What about DUNE, the original.

Epic. #1.

Yannick
Yannick

Solaris (the remake - i haven't seen the original, but the remake just captured me), Moon (although not underrated, certainly not appreciated enough), 12 Monkeys, The first half of Sunshine, before it turns into a cheap slasher, The Man from Earth, Immortal: ad vitam (French movie), Contact.

BContreras7
BContreras7

What about "SUNSHINE" by Danny Boyle

hoopleton
hoopleton

Monsters (2010). Absolutely beautiful film.

Gourd
Gourd

I loved Dark City, nice to see it on the list. I don't know if its underrated, and it certainly had an all-star cast, but 12 Monkeys is one of my favorite Sci-Fi movies. Going to go watch Primer now . . .

JCO
JCO

Sunshine.

one-legged_tarzan!
one-legged_tarzan!

The others I might add, except I'm not sure they really were underrated at the time, are The Man Who Fell to Earth, and Weld am Draht.  I also  loved Iron Sky but I am not sure if it really counts as sci-fi.  It's more like a fairy tale.  But it is set on the moon, so...

bbocaner
bbocaner

I'd add Moon (2009) and The Man From Earth (2007). I'd perhaps subtract Serenity: I don't think it was underrated. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed the TV show and the movie, but I don't think it is a masterpiece and I think there is a lot of appreciation for it already. Certainly not underrated?

Totally agree about Primer. When it came out on DVD I must have watched it five times in a row to sort everything out. The production values are low, yes, but the story and the way in which it is presented is brilliant.

Loved Gattaca. Most impressive for me is the mood it sets with the costumes, sets, cinematography, props, and the wonderful score.

JeffRaber
JeffRaber

2 additions to the list for me. Both of them Sci-Fi remakes of Westerns.

#1. Battle Beyond the Stars. 1980. This is the post Star Wars version of The Magnificent 7 (or 7 Samurai if you're really a film geek). The special effects were directed by some guy named James Cameron. For the uber-geeks out there- many of the ships used in the film piloted by the "good guys" are the inspiration for the ships in the video game Star Control (1990- Commodore Amiga)

Considering it's usually rated 1-2 stars it can only be "underrated"- but it's also awesome, if for no other reason than the hero's ship is a flying uterus -with- fallopian tube laser cannons.

#2 Precious Find 1996: Starring Rutger Hauer and Joan Chen. A sci-fi remake of "The Treasure of the Sierra Madre". Also starring Brion James (yep- they're getting the Blade Runner band back together). Universally reviled... but could it be ahead of it's time in the manner of ...

Bonus entry: #3 "They Live" 1988. Any list of underrated scifi movies without this one on it is not worth reading.

emintey
emintey

The only one of the movies listed that i have seen is The Fountain, and it is one of my favorite all time movies. IMO it is right up there with 2001: A Space Odyssey, or better.

rkngel
rkngel

Good list of underrated sci-fi flicks. I love Dark City, Gattaca and Serenity. Another one I'd add, although not quite sci-fi, more fantasy (but then sci-fi really is just fantasy with rivets on, in the words of Terry Pratchett) is The Dark Crystal by Jim Henson and Frank Oz.

AaronTester
AaronTester

One movie that I believe is a must watch is "Солярис" (Solaris).  No, not the Soderbergh travesty from 2002, but the 1972 masterpiece done by Andrei Tarkovsky.  The Soviet Union's answer to 2001: A Space Odyssey, it is a stark counterpoint to the cold and sterile view of Kubric's universe and speaks more about what it means to be human and the soul (not to mention the role of Hari is performed by the beautiful Natalja Bondarchuk).  If you have never seen it, you have really missed out.

GabrielCisneros
GabrielCisneros like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

"Forbidden Planet" (1956) Probably one of the first films to combine animation with live action (sparingly) to great effect.  It tells the story of a rescue mission to a far off planet.  The only survivors of a mysterious attack on the now defunct research team are an aging scientist and his beautiful  teen age daughter.  The tech discovered on this now uninhabited planet includes an massively energy intensive 'machine' that can 'manifest' any object that the mind is capable of imagining, including tigers and a T-bone steak should you disre one.  The all male rescue crew is reminiscent of a WWII navy ship with the drunk cook, a muscular First Mate and - of course - the infalible Captain who slowly discovers the reason for the mysterious disappearance of the once all-powerful society.  The clue resides in the Freudian postulation known as the Id - "the dark, inaccessible part of our personality . . . that . . . can be described only as a contrast to the ego. We approach the id with analogies: we call it a chaos, a cauldron full of seething excitations."  -Freud (Wiki)

notLostInSpace
notLostInSpace like.author.displayName 1 Like

@GabrielCisneros What is the definition of underrated?  I think Forbidden Planet is a classic and well known and well liked by sci fans over the age of 40, so it is hard to call it underrated.  Underrated movies are ones that did not get much popularity nor viewers.  The opposite is when something is acclaimed for being so great and everyone sees it, ie Star Wars.  In my eyes, Star Wars (all of them) are vastly over rated silly children movies.  I have not seen all the movies on this list, but loved Silent Running.

dehbiknits
dehbiknits

I was hoping that someone would mention "Silent Running," one of my all-time favorites.  I cry through that movie every time that I see it.

dalegray
dalegray

@GabrielCisneros Sorry I put unlike, I wasnt trying to, I actually love Forbidden Planet,,,I think Gene Roddenberry got his ideas from this movie.

SueHannon
SueHannon like.author.displayName 1 Like

Gattaca and Dark City are two of my favorite sci-fi movies - I never understood why they didn't get widespread love! Also love Serenity. Never saw Silent Running orPrimer; will have to look for them.

I also really liked The Island, an under-the-radar sci-fi thriller starring Ewan MacGregor, Scarlett Johannsen, Sean Bean, Steve Buscemi, set in the near future.

Rodbig
Rodbig

A little known movie called hunter prey is a great one to catch.  kind of like enemy mine, but shot on a really low budget, and shot very well. and Equilibrium is always a notable addition.

drewallstar
drewallstar like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

Attack the Block is my guilty pleasure. The slang, the context, the kids' lives all ring true

Ben_Z_Music
Ben_Z_Music

From Beyond/Reanimator 1986/1985

Demon Seed 1977

Another Earth 2011

Primer 2004

Ben_Z_Music
Ben_Z_Music like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

Add all the Cube movies

and They Live 1988

BelindaLuscombe
BelindaLuscombe

Steven, Steven, Steven. You must let The Fountain go. It needs to leave earth and not be seen by humans again. It can flaot through space in a big bubble and then despoil the eyeballs of creatures on another planets. Even naked-ish bald Hugh Jackman cannot save it. Gattaca though definitely. No love For Another Earth? Too slow? Logans Run? Wall*e?

MrObvious
MrObvious like.author.displayName 1 Like

Dark City, excellent choice. Love Serenity as well. Although the show was better and the movie kind of punctuated that with several main characters dying.

kngfupanda
kngfupanda like.author.displayName 1 Like

There is nothing more underrated than page not found.

mattpeckham
mattpeckham moderator

@kngfupanda Sorry all, fixed!

AllenBonslett
AllenBonslett like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

I also think Moon is much better and more underrated than Serenity, Sam Rockwell was stunning in it. Really though, I liked Serenity a lot. I saw Silent Running as a bright eyed 12 year old in the theaters back then, Serenity and  The Fountain in the theaters, have owned Dark City since it came out and have seen Primer on IFC 4 or 5 times and place it in my 'it blows me away' category.

PeterNikols
PeterNikols like.author.displayName 1 Like

Steven, I agree with you on the list. I strongly believe that The Fountain is a masterpiece at so many levels and so much better than Daren's later works like the Wrestler and Black Swan. I am also glad that Brad Pitt turned down the role because i can't picture him in the movie at all. 

RyanJohnson
RyanJohnson

Love Dark City. I would add West World, Logan's Run, and Damnation Alley to your list.