Lawsuit Alleges That Heroes‘ Final Year Was A Rip-Off

Poor Heroes. First NBC cancels the series (Although creator Tim Kring said yesterday that he’s “finalizing [a] discussion about a number of ways to keep the ‘Heroes’ universe alive for its fans,” whatever that may mean) and then it gets slapped with a $60 million lawsuit alleging that its final season ripped off a little-known independent comic book.

The lawsuit has been filed by comic creator Jazan Wild (or, if you’d prefer to use his real name, Jason Barnes), who claims that the NBC superhero soap’s fourth season contained elements that were “virtually identical” to his 2005 series Jazan Wild’s Carnival of Souls. Admittedly, the idea of a mysterious and spooky carnival filled with people with magical abilities and unpleasant motives may not be entirely original to Wild, but the complaint’s point-by-point comparison, which includes images from both Carnival and Heroes and is now online at Comic Book Resources’ Robot 6 blog, does seem slightly more convincing.

Wild is suing NBC Universal, NBC Studios and Tim Kring’s Tailwind Productions for $60 million in compensatory and punitive damages for copyright infringement, intentional interference with prospective economic advantage, unfair competition and unjust enrichment, as well as seeking to prevent the already-completed fourth season from ever being re-broadcast.

More On Techland:

NBC’s The Cape is Heroes Done Wrong

Marvel Fights For Spidey, Mutants

Related Topics: Carnival of Souls, heroes, Jazan Wild, NBC, tv, Unlikely lawsuits, Gaming & Culture, News
  • http://youtube.com/churchhatestucker Church

    Wait. Isn’t that the clown from Spawn?

  • richardsrussell

    What about “The Vampire’s Assistant: Cirque d’Freak”? Lots of magical people in THAT carnival, too.

    Do you suppose George Harrison’s “My Sweet Lord” defense will hold up here?

  • http://juggala.wordpress.com juggala

    Haha, dudes tring to sue Heroes cuz their carival has a house of mirrors too!

    Thats like Betty White tring to sue another wrinkly lady for stealing her looks. The world is full of tremendous letdowns in human intelligence.

  • tyrantking

    I think that guy ripped off the care bears movie a little bit. Oh and every other movie, tv show and/or comic book set in a carnival ever.

  • secretmantra

    @Church:

    You win.

  • deedeer

    I looked over the entire lawsuit posted at courthouse.com at this link;

    http://www.courthousenews.com/2010/05/17/Heroes.pdf

    My thoughts before reading it was basically, here’s another bogus suit. After reading the pdf it is very clear that he was plagiarized.

    It has many story sections that are the same. The pictures strenghthen the stolen story. Not a chance that this many things happen by accident. Someone copied the guy. I think he got a pretty raw deal by the looks of the comments above. The suit is not about carnivals. It’s about these 2 stories.

blog comments powered by Disqus