Why The Clone Wars is The Work Of The Sith

Here’s the secret about Star Wars: The Clone Wars, the CGI-animated television series that fits in between movies of George Lucas’ grand generational saga that takes place a long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away, etc. etc.: It may be the most truly cruel, bordering on outright evil, show on television.

Oh, sure; you can’t really tell that from the show itself. Individually, each episode is alternately thrilling, funny or – if it’s an episode that includes Jar-Jar Binks – really difficult to get through without throwing something at the television, and even devoted followers of the series who aren’t familiar with the movies – Although, admittedly, I’m not entirely sure how that could happen, but still – might be missing the sheer heartbreaking nature of the show. But to everyone else, Clone Wars should be regarded as little more than a cruel, cruel trick on fans and members of the 501st worldwide. Because The Clone Wars is, ultimately, all about the pointlessness and futility of… well, everything.

The key to just how insanely depressing The Clone Wars is, is the final movie, Episode III: Revenge Of The Sith. You all remembered that one, right? It’s the one where Anakin – who, to put things in the proper perspective, is the hero of The Clone Wars – succumbs to the dark side of the Force, turns on his teachings, and kills lots of Jedi, including all the kids who’re in training. So, yeah; the hero of the series turns his back on everything he’s been fighting for, and kills his former comrades. And some kids, just to ram home how evil he’s become.

(The ultimate fate of the series’ cast is, by accident or design, ridiculously bleak: The majority – if not all – of the core Jedi seen in the show end up dead by the end of Revenge of The Sith, either on-screen or by inference from that whole “All the Jedi are dead apart from the ones we show later” thing. The clone troopers and Republic officers go on to serve the intergalactic Nazi-esque Empire, and even the Sith separatists will be mostly dead by the time the dust settles. Only Obi-Wan, Yoda, R2-D2 and C3-PO really survive unscathed, with Anakin’s sidekick Ahsoka Tano’s fate entirely unknown, but most likely tragic. They should do an episode where they freeze-frame on various characters and go on to reveal what they ended up doing, like at the end of Animal House, but just keep flashing up the word “DEAD” over and over again.)

Related Topics: anakin skywalker, clone wars, episode III: revenge of the sith, george lucas has a plan and it is evil, HE CHOPPED OFF HIS LEGS, jedi, movies, obi-wan kenobi, sith, star wars, star wars month, star wars: the clone wars, sucks to be a youngling, the clone wars, tv, yoda, Gaming & Culture
  • http://crichton007.wordpress.com crichton007

    Blah, blah, blah: filler.

    This is a good mostly family friendly show. Just enjoy it.

  • mcy75

    Just because it made you a bitter person does not mean kids will end up that way. Take some prozac and enjoy the show.

  • g3peto

    No, they’re doomed.

  • lincutious

    Ok Graeme, I am sure that you know all of these stories have been written already….right?
    The clone wars cartoon simply redresses the books in a visual format and adds more cashflow to Lucas of course. But you can read and or listen to any of these stories, or at least ones immediately surrounding them in the time line of the whole series which by the way goes well beyond Lukes grandchildren into the “future” of the saga.

  • http://figerrific.wordpress.com/ figerrific

    I don’t think Graeme’s showing any particular bitterness. I agree it’s a fantastic show, but it’s short-sighted to say “Oh, it’s just good fun, just enjoy!”. His assessment is that children will enjoy it so much that they’ll get into Star Wars lore and find that the hero that introduced them to the universe turns into a weak willed crybaby that goes absolutely genocidal. I’m not saying it’s going to make children go crazy, it would be at least disheartening. Imagine in 20 years they do a Harry Potter cartoon where Voldemort is the hero, it’s about the same as that.

  • http://youtube.com/churchhatestucker Church

    I’m working on a new cartoon myself. The working title is “Young Hitler.” Can someone get me a pitch meeting with George?

  • http://djtrudeau.wordpress.com djtrudeau

    For me, it’s not so much about the bleakness of it all as much as how it undercuts the themes Lucas supposedly cared so much about. In the movies, he tries to portray the Clone Wars as a great tragedy. On the show, they’re a rootin-tootin adventure where our good guys are fighting the evil separatist bad guys.

    It’s interesting to me that to modern kids, Clone Wars and the Prequels are the Star Wars they care the most about. They view the original trilogy like a footnote. It might be a thing where as they age and it takes more than flashing lightsabers to entertain them, they might come to regard the original films higher. I still contend that in 100 years, the original trilogy will still be enjoyed and the other material will be simply noted as the throwaway entertainment it is.

  • moge703

    I see your point Graeme, but for the older crowd, Clone Wars fills in the gaps and the details of the Clone Wars that we have been missing ever since Luke and Obi-Wan talked about them in A New Hope.

    Unfortunately, yeah, it’s coming to us in cartoon form, since it was neglected and seemed almost trivial in the prequel movies.

  • guymont

    All I can say is that the series is far better than the live-action AotC.

  • tereglith

    I think that the true cruelty of the show is that, in the holocron, it counts as G-canon, meaning that it overwrites the much more nuanced, continuitous, and simply better canon layed down by the novels, which are all (I believe) C-canon.

  • slabtzu

    Few saw the significance of your input in this thread. I understand what youre saying completely and thought the same myself early on. Story telling is always connected with the real world. That’s the secret to fiction.

    In our era, the original trilogy taught us the empire is a bad thing, revolutionaries are good. Very simple, but thanks to George Lucas by the time I got to the political science courses in college, my politics were already prepared since I was 5. I saw the same patterns all over the world, imperial puppet regimes, economic and military repression in Latin America, Africa and Asia with bloody money trails leading back to today’s Republic/Empire. Globalization brings about a natural forming of a Rebel Alliance (ie. foreign aid activists like Cynthia McKinney and Charles Baron breaking through Israeli naval blockades to bring crayons to Palestine, US celebrities befriending the Vietnamese Revolutionary Army all come to mind). It takes allot of heart and courage found in the heroes and sheroes of Star Wars to tackle this reality.

    The generation you addressed growing up on Clone Wars, is growing up in an era of never ending wars, deceit and lies in our mainstream media and government that results in a brutal massive lost of life as an everyday reality, kept hidden from our news by law. That is what we must understand, Lucas isn’t just into making money – “if you’re not with me, then you’re my enemy” – Anakin. “You are either with me or against me” – Bush.

    What Obama really means by pulling out the troops from Iraq this month, is 94 US bases are to remain, 50,000 US troops to remain and 11,000 armed private mercenaries to remain until the 20 year oil contracts run out. They are growing up in the generation of the first black president who is killing people of color worldwide, sending troops to Colombia, Costa Rica, bombing Somalia, Kenya and the Congo etc etc. In Clone Wars, there was an episode where Palpatine argues the Democrat Party belief that an increase in troops will end the war sooner and bring about peace, as Padme was trying to convince the senate its time to negotiate peace and stop escalating war.

    Our children need this cartoon, more than our generation. When they begin to leave their preteen years and enter their teens and early college years there will hopefully be a darker Star Wars TV show by then, which covers the beginning of the Rebel Alliance, the surviving underground Jedi, and the fascist state which will in some way mirror the growing police state crises all cities in the United States suffer. Many revolutionaries (all of which fought for equality and fundamental rights) were assassinated and killed in the 70’s … these stories are slowly getting out now. It may happen again.

    In this “evil” as you frame it, is actually the hard truth our future will need to survive and take control. In there they will find hope and the stories of courage it takes to stand up against the “evil” you describe. I believe Asoka will not die in this series even if it was originally written that way. Unlike her Jedi sisters and brothers who died under order 66, unlike the dozens and dozens of Black Panthers who were systematically murdered before a New Hope came out, Asoka will go into exile like Assata and inspire. There is always more to Star Wars than meets the eye.

blog comments powered by Disqus