How Egypt Cut Off the Internet (and How a U.S. ‘Kill Switch’ Might Work)

REUTERS/Amr Dalsh

Reports have now verified that Eqypt has cut off access to the internet amid political protests. Renesys, an internet monitoring firm based in Manchester, New Hampshire, calls the situation "an action unprecedented in Internet history," according to a company blog post.

The development of an internet "kill switch" that our own government could use in the case of a national emergency has been proposed here in the U.S., and if we take a look at how Egypt has already flipped its own kill switch, it may give us more insight into how such a system would work here.

The Basics of an Internet Connection

On the simplest of levels, your computer connects to the internet through an internet service provider (ISP)—Comcast, Time Warner, Qwest, Verizon, etc.—and your service provider either connects directly to all the other internet service providers around the world or to a larger internet service provider that then connects to all the others.

When you open up your web browser and type a domain name into the address bar—say Time.com, for instance—your service provider sends a lightning-quick request to whichever service provider Time.com uses to make its web pages publicly available on the internet.

The computer that holds all of Time.com’s web pages sends a response back through its internet service provider basically saying, "Yes, we’re online. Here’s the web page you requested."

The Border Gateway Protocol

In order for ISPs to establish broader connections between the computers on their networks and the rest of the computers on the internet, traffic is routed through the Border Gateway Protocol (BGP). Egypt’s ISPs have a certain amount of machine-readable internet protocol (IP) addresses that are used to identify connected computers across the internet, and the BGP makes the active IP addresses visible to the rest of the world to facilitate connections.

Related Topics: egypt, internet, internet, internet access, web, Gadgets, News
  • http://spiritfilledpoetry.wordpress.com CommentatorandPoet

    I have no doubt that our current President and his henchmen would dance with joy at having such an option under the Obama administration. Today, even the average brain-dead citizen of this country realizes that our current left-wing administration is out to destroy the very foundations of our great nation.

  • http://www.reinventingtheeventhorizon.wordpress.com Kathryn McCullough

    Great post and congrats on being freshly pressed!
    blogging from Haiti,
    Kathy

  • http://aisjournal.com Sajib

    It’s just lame.

  • http://antisocialthoughts.wordpress.com Mitch Leuraner

    I didn’t realize that they just stopped the DNS servers. Seems like a strange way to go about this… if the government can tell ISPs to stop DNS, then they could just as easily tell ISP to cut off access properly. That would be a lot more likely to work. As it is, all customers need to do is find someone who knowns the OpenDNS or Google DNS server addresses.

  • http://dionekolodka.wordpress.com YouGetWellSoon

    I cannot comment as to how Obama is handling internet access but I do know that US media under Bush purposely neglected to report about the war and how things were ‘going’. Every other country got more info and more video footage. With internet control too – no one would be getting any 411 about it’s own country’s goings-on.
    It’s a scary thought – controlling information controls the people. It’s happening in the far east (China and North Korea) but only the people can stop it from happening here.

  • http://milieus.wordpress.com milieus

    The US shouldn’t be allowed to do that. Wouldn’t that go completely against freedom of speech? Yes, yes it would.

  • http://deewhitsett.net deewhitsett

    The intelligence agency invinted the www and I assume all of it layers and protocals.My point being is that they might say they are working on a kill switch,and that to me means that they already have several versions they are testing.

  • http://rohitmaiya.wordpress.com rohitmaiya

    Isn’t is similar to the US trying to pressurise Wikileaks from leaking more.

    Not that I support Egyptian Govt cutting off the internet. If US is advising, then they have to look at themselves first.

    US secretly wants Mubarak in power. Thats what one source says.

  • http://jroycroft.wordpress.com J Roycroft

    Obama and Internet access are not a good mix. Gov’t needs to stay out of the internet.

  • http://humanitarikim.wordpress.com humanitarikim

    I’m not sure why people are pointing the finger at Obama concerning an internet kill switch. The Government has been covering up things and hiding information from us for years.

  • harebell

    Usual bots having a go at theories about what Obama may or may not be doing. Did you have anything to say about what GWB actually did do? Or is it only the centre that concerns you?

  • http://notesfromrumblycottage.wordpress.com notesfromrumbleycottage

    What is happening in Eygpt right now is horrifying. The reasons behind the protests are sad and head-shaking. I understand why a government would want to do this but I believe they are clueless as to why it is happening. Do leaders think only by the computer we can communicate?

  • http://floresk.wordpress.com floresk

    Bad, bad idea.

  • http://wadingacross.wordpress.com wadingacross

    Cutting off internet in Egypt hurts the democratic movement there. I suspect it doesn’t hurt the Muslim Brotherhood.

    Egypt is in a no-win situation right now. They’re surrounded by Libya and Sudan who’re both friendly to the Muslim Brotherhood. Mubarak’s son has been seen as incompetent to do his father’s job, which would mean a weak government or a power vacuum.

    Hosni has hamstrung his nation in his effort to squash the fundamentalists and the democratists so as to maintain power.

    The Muslim Brotherhood are effectively the godfathers or grandfathers of the modern fundamentalist/Islamic terrorist organizations. They’ve been in Egypt for decades. Contrast that to Iraq which had no similar situation while under the domination of Saddam.

    There is zero garauntee that any Democratic revolution in Egypt is going to produce a strong, stable government remotely similar to Iraq after Saddam was removed from power.

    If Hosni were smart, he’d start trying to build up the Democratic movement in his nation as fast as possible – and that means open internet – otherwise he is leaving his nation open to the Muslim Brotherhood and their descendants.

  • http://mycameramyfriend.wordpress.com My Camera, My Friend

    If someone turned off internet access in the US, lots of people would riot about that alone.

  • http://jillshill.wordpress.com jillshill

    Doesn’t this kind of work how that situation in “Oceans 11″?
    Now that our government “see’s” whats going on in Egypt, they will figure out a “real kill switch” in case they wanted to do this?
    Like all they have to see is what worked, what did not, and move from there….

  • http://thejamminjabber.wordpress.com thejamminjabber

    Taking censorship to tha next level.

  • cydonos

    If the idea is to cut off all communication, Just shutting down DNS would be very ineffective if the people are prepared for it.

    All you have to do is use the windows hosts file to hardcode the IP addresses for a few key websites and poof! You don’t get cut off, at least temporarily.

    For a more permanent solution, a person might set up computers on both sides with static IP addresses, and send information in and out of the country that way.

  • mdavidn

    The Egyptians shut off their internet by removing themselves from IP routing tables worldwide. In other words, their routers told everyone else that Egypt has no computers on the internet.

    When your ISP receives a request bound for Egypt, they no longer know where to send it. The same is true of Time.com’s internet provider.

    It’s called BGP. This had nothing to do with DNS!

  • http://thewildhearts.wordpress.com thewildhearts

    This is crazy!

  • http://achilliad.wordpress.com achilliad

    Only a dictatorship-style “government” would do such a thing, and fortunately WE do not currently have that scenario. As for ComCOST, never use them, boycott them with all you might as they are currently in the process of ruining a cherished and original television network with dire consequences on the horizon for NBC – soon to be known as the Nominal Broadcasting Company.

  • RLTJ’s

    As a neutral observer in a neutral country I see only a fool tightening the nose around his neck, lifting a rock to drop it on his own feet.

    Calling for a snap election, not running for re-election, with his puppets, if any, doing the same, is I think his nicest way out.

  • RLTJ’s

    Its funny, what Americans see as left is something we see yet right. The world of politics is indeed, like the Earth, round. :-)

  • http://leadinglight.wordpress.com leadinglight

    I think this action is foolish. Besides have they cut off communication by phone and such? The internet is not the only messenger tool available.

    As for the US thing, I know when an internet filter was proposed here in Australia that there was a huge backlash against it. We even do not have a First Amendment. So I doubt a Internet kill switch would be favourably received.

  • http://butterflyjewel.wordpress.com Butterfly Jewel

    Interesting to say the least…Today, so many people have included the Internet as part of their daily lives and routines to the point of any interruption with access causing problems in basic communications (E-mail, phone, etc.) and major disruptions in their daily functioning. Not only that but many jobs rely on the Internet to successfully complete tasks. I wonder how it affects those in Egypt politically, socially, economically, financially, and so on.

  • http://www.scottystarnes.com Scotty Starnes

    I wrote about this myself. We also have to be mindful of the fact that the Obama administration is tied closely to Google. The same Google that admitted to stealing passwords, emails and IP addresses. This is the same administration that is pushing for ‘net-neutrality,’ making it easier to wiretap the internet and creating internet IDs for Americans. If the government is allowed to have a ‘kill switch’ the same thing that is happening in Egypt could happen in the US.

  • consciousconsciousness

    if you can’t figure out why America wouldn’t do the same thing to its citizens, go to hulu.com and look up “The American Ruling Class.”

    Is there an American ruling class? Of course.
    How powerful are they?
    Walter Cronkite can answer that better than i can… and he does.

  • http://densonman.wordpress.com densonman

    stiffling the free flow of informationto of an informed people will only lead to other ingenuos ways of doing things: rumours,lies ,plots, over gear strategies that will be counter productive for censorship. Those who govern should be accountable to their citizens otherwise they don’t have any business clonning.The internet is here to stay!!

  • http://alicewandering.wordpress.com Alice

    Today, in Mumbai, we are observing a No TV Day because a leading national daily suggested it and campaigned for it. I’m not watching the news channels, so I haven’t seen any report on Egypt. The only way I know what’s going on is because the same daily is also tweeting news on Egypt. I can read this blog post via the internet. Makes one wonder at the marvels and shortcomings of technology.
    How would we respond to a day in our lives without TV and internet?

  • http://thebackwoodsphilosoper.wordpress.com Mad Jack

    That kill switch doesn’t sound so crazy anymore. Don’t expect this to show up in the New York TImes.

  • http://kontua.wordpress.com kontua

    :))))))

  • Leslie

    What is it about America that it produces so many paranoid individuals?

  • http://www.CoreyMondello.com cpmondello

    OBAMA ADMINISTRATION DID NOT START THIS. Nixon is the most well-known president who wanted “king-like” power, and when he was denied this, his cohorts spent the next three decades letting their anger brew until they were allowed to get a boob like George W. Bush elected then illegally appointed as the president. These people were Rumsfeld, Cheney, Ashcroft, and others who couldnt wait until a “Pearl Harbor-like” incident happened, so they could pass their already created “Patriot Act” that gives the President, ultimate powers, trumping all US laws and the US Constitution. So for all those who blame Obama or the “Left” for this, first, you should thank the “Left” for making it possible for people to be allowed to take bathroom breaks at work, secondly, I’ll say to you, what was said to me, by many people, when I was called a terrorist, treasonous, nazi (etc..) when I brought up my concerns with the Bush’s administration: “If you don’t like it, leave”.

  • http://stopbuyingdrugs.wordpress.com AkJ

    I was hoping this article would demonstrate the possibility of the U.S. eventually doing the same if similar protests erupted here. But instead of showing how little government normally cares about free speech when their jobs are in danger, I got a simplified, yet drawn out explanation of the TCP handshake.

  • http://mentalityunhinged.wordpress.com Mentality

    I do wonder what turning the internet off would actually proove? What does cutting these people off from the outside world prove? They must have something to hide if they feel the need to stop people on the outside seeing what is going on and stopping the people on the inside discussing it with the outside world.

    I don’t believe any government likes the fact there is so much free speech online and the fact people get to discuss any issues. They are paranoid, and to a degree probably should be. “If their” people” are unhappy, and it is the vast majority, they have reason to worry, they are doing something wrong, but would never change it because of their own interests. These people are standing up for what they believe in and because THEY have something to prove, because THEY have something to say. The governments are ok until we disagree with decisons and want to stand upto them. Why should their word be final, because it’s in our best interest? no not really because they are in a better position than us and the decision does not affect them the same as it affects us. Yet we sit back 90% of the time and let it happen.

    All countries have jumped on this band wagon that the country is in debt, and we need to start wiping of the debt, what makes me wonder is for example. America has debt to the UK, the UK has debt to America? Well surely one would cancel out the other?

    The sensible thing to do would be to just wipe the debt, money isn’t real!!! I would love nothing more in my life than to see money obolished.

    Zeitgiest!

  • http://martinjgreen.wordpress.com Martin J. Green

    Um, dude, while the end result described in your article is correct, the technical details are not. What the renesys article is describing is the removal of 3,500 BGP records, nothing to do with DNS, rather these control routing; thus ensuring outbound traffic has nowhere to go. It’s thus way more fundamental than just dns – Egypt is for an intents and purposes disconnected from the internet… And you should update your article with the correct technical info :)

  • http://shythom.wordpress.com shythom

    To CommandandatorPoet,

    Yeah – because a right wing administration would NEVER do the exact same thing if they could.

    Sounds like you’re level of intelligence is below even those half-wits out there.

  • http://negkreyol.wordpress.com negkreyol

    They more inform you are government becomes paranoid. The massess are gradually becoming more demanding of thier repective government and it a move that George Orwell spoke about In Animal fan.

  • http://www.trutherator.wordpress.com trutherator

    “Paranoid individuals”? The problem is so many trusting individuals who forget Gulf of Tonkin, MK Ultra, racist syphilis experiments, experimental vaccines (first human beta probably) on soldiers in the first Gulf War, the USS Madrid in Havana Bay, the “magic bullet”, Nixon’s White House plumbers, IRS audits of every one of Clinton’s prominent detractors in the 1990s, on and on it goes.

    Yahoo has already given me a “warning” web page on some web destinations that I click on in my search. More than once, and just today.

    One of those was to a web page where a document tech took apart Obama’s web-posted birth certificate (NOT the long form). Heck, I would like to see a refutation of that analysis but can’t find any such thing.

    I don’t believe all such things, but Yahoo told me “Yahoo does not approve this web page. Click at your own risk”. It was a page at atlasshrugged.com.

    Got another such one today, from Yahoo but this one was a “malware” warning. I knew the link was good so I clicked through THREE WEB PAGES! to get to there.

    AND IT WAS A WORDPRESS.COM BLOG! This one:

    https://missouritenth.wordpress.com/

    Google did a couple of tricks behind the scene too, with the aforementioned atlasshrugged.com web site. I have sharp disagreements with the owner but I HATE CENSORSHIP WITH A PASSION.

    https://www.eff.org/https-everywhere

    –trutherator
    http://www.trutherator.wordpress.com

  • http://www.trutherator.wordpress.com trutherator

    And Walter Cronkite is PART of the American Ruling Class, along with George Soros, Kissinger, the Rockefellers, and others of their socialist ilk. Because socialism is a fraud perpetrated on the rest of us by the American Ruling Class and its parental Global Ruling Class, designed to get the poor and powerless to demand stronger enslavement.

    http://www.trutherator.wordpress.com

  • http://thelocalguide.wordpress.com thelocalguide

    I think that if a govnerment decides to cut the communications to its citizens it’s pretty much a act of WAR against its own people.

    Even if there is a group of dangerous individuals using the phone, internet or television (this includes politics brainwashing) for their purposes I’m sure that the majority of people can’t be blamed for the sins of a minory.

  • http://barefootmeds.wordpress.com barefoot_med_student

    Mh… very interesting, even for someone who is not too clued up on the initimate workings of the net.
    If you are interested in what’s going on in Egypt, check the events from the view of an Egyptian teenage girl. This is also a very good up-and-coming journalism organisation: http://youthjournalisminternational.blogspot.com/2011/01/inside-egyptian-revolution.html

  • http://spiritfilledpoetry.wordpress.com CommentatorandPoet

    If “Paranoid” means that Americans have not had their head up their A_ _, that would explain why we are not ruled by a King or a Dictator (so far) for over two hundred years.

  • http://kristianigee.wordpress.com DJ GFire

    If we look into what Egypt is doing, it’s definitely not a surprise to me at all. The United States may very well be heading in that direction, saldy enough. I believe that this Net Neutrality legislation is not what it is all cracked up to be. If the government has direct access to all internet traffic, come on people, what does that mean? All we need now is the antichrist, right?

  • http://mobilegenius.wordpress.com JM

    It is pretty impressive, and worrisome, how quickly and thoroughly they cut of access. This would work in this country as well…don’t assume we are so different.

  • http://theprogrammingkid.wordpress.com theprogrammingkid

    if the internet was shut down i would cry

  • http://fameliciouz1.wordpress.com fameliciouz1

    Hi.. Didnt read so much bout this. But is it US that demanded this??

    http://fameliciouz.blogg.no/

  • http://zainabkhawaja.wordpress.com Zainab Khawaja

    To have an internet kill switch in the United States would go against all the values that this country stands for. Freedom, equality, the right to choose. Democracy stands for the right of the people over the government. No matter how good their intentions, this kind of thing would be nothing short of catastrophic. On a side note,
    I love the layout of your blog.
    Congrats on being freshly pressed!

    Do check out my blog if you have a chance!

  • http://4gallantecology.wordpress.com gallantecology

    Leslie… despite its huge economy and its tech-sector, remember the USA is a populace with a religious mindset, so there may lie the answer to you question.

    Maybe we should keep a stash of modems and get prepared to bring back an underground network of BBS’s.

  • http://freedombytheway.wordpress.com Freedom, by the way

    It’s not paranoia. It’s reality. There are very few areas of our lives that the government hasn’t either exerted some measure of control–or has tried to. Because of that, many Americans are wary. And rightly so.

    Thanks for the informative post.

  • ipisking

    Funny how everyone says the Government should stay away from the internet when it was the Government that gave everyone the internet in the 1st place. You don’t think that since the Gov handed most of the internet over to the corporations that they don’t have a way to stop all of the internet traffic by type and user.. Think again…..

  • http://www.crossharpchronicles.wordpress.com/profiles/blogs/promote-your-music-on-the-2 David W. King

    @consciousconsciousness, I just watched the American Ruling Class. I enjoyed the way it was presented. Brought up a number of salient points worth consideration, from the point on philanthropy to the idea that the founding fathers set up the constitution to protect the ruling class here in the US.

    Thanks for this recommendation. Passing it along, I would recommend that everything watch this and watch it twice as so much is covered.

  • http://richardbelltheword.wordpress.com richardbelltheword

    It really doesn’t matter who’s president, the idea of a “kill switch” for the U.S. internet is abhorrent to anyone who cares about freedom. If the results of the 2008 election had been reversed, we would still be hearing the same discussion about a U.S. kill switch. Regardless of what comes out of their mouths, there are very, very few examples of any national leader turning down an opportunity to expand his or her power. President Bush, for example, did all kinds of things to expand the power of the executive, acts which increased the power of the state over the individual. Civil libertarians decried these actions, and there were plenty of attacks on Bush. Yet President Obama has barely touched these Bush power grabs.

    That’s why we have to fight these power grabs so hard when a President first makes them. Once any president succeeds in yet another rollback of our constitutional rights, it’s very difficult to get any subsequent administration to surrender such power.

  • http://whenquiet.wordpress.com whenquiet

    “Like a roaring lion and a charging bear
    Is a wicked ruler over poor people” Proverbs 28:15

    “When the wicked arise, men hide themselves:
    but when they perish, the righteous increase” Proverbs 28:28

    “And their dead bodies will lie in the street of the great city which spiritually is called Sodom and Egypt, where also our Lord was crucified.” Revelation 12:8

    “Great and marvelous are Your works,
    Lord God Almighty!
    Just and true are your ways
    O king of the saints!
    Who shall not fear You, O Lord, and glorify
    Your name?
    For You alone are holy.
    For all nations shall come and worship before
    You.
    For your judgments have been manifested” Revelatons 15:1-4

    *Bigger than the internet

  • http://londonstockmarket.wordpress.com London Stock Market

    it just tells you alot about whats is happeneing and how uncle sam can control the planet.

  • http://krazy2h.wordpress.com krazy2h

    This is crazy, internet is something really necessary for all of us i think Egypt’s citizens must be sad but anyway public DNS works very well

  • http://veronicamullally.wordpress.com Veronica Mullally

    Power to the people of Egypt

  • riffenberg

    Are you serious? Do you actually see nothing wrong with this? Censorship! That’s the first thing a dictator does is get control of the press.The press is the internet. That way the only information the population gets is the info. the dictator puts out. The Dems are pushing for control of the media and so is Obama. Regardless of the airheaded moon beams out there that think this is just a dandy idea he’ll have quite a fight on his hands if he tries this. Obama wants his national police force too. He’s a dictator in waiting.

  • bettiepage9000

    Please explain, step by step, how I can manually configure a wireless router to connect through Google’s free DNS server,I guess,instead of using my service provider which happens to be Sprint, using my unlimited access, Sprint AirCard: Sierra Wireless 597E communicating at 921,600 BPS, soon to be replaced with a new 4G air card.And my older Dell C610 laptop is also soon to be replaced with a new, fast laptop with at least 2GB RAM memory. Please explain what the tricky parts are , and how it works. OR, WHAT COULD I DO AS AN ALTERNATE WAY TO CONNECT TO THE INTERNET, USING MY AIRCARD RECONFIGURED DIFFERENTLY INCASE SOME SOME CORRUPT, CON-ARTIST POLITICIAN SHUTS DOWN MY REGULAR WAY TO CONNECT TO THE INTERNET, KNOWING THAT ALL I USE NOW TO CONNECT TO THE INTERNET IS MY SPRINT Sierra wireless 597E AirCard PLUGGED INTO THE EXPRESS PORT ON MY DELL C610 LAPTOP. I don’t even own any other kind of modem, or own a wireless router. I don’t have a land line either. Just a T-Mobile cell phone with unlimited access. I am shopping for a faster service for cell phone too, as I could hardly get or make any calls without being outdoors for the last 7 months, every since the T-Mobile tower on the rooftop on the corner got struck by lightening, and caught the roof on fire burning up all the several company’s microwave towers that were also right there with it. All the retard cellphone companies and their installers did not realize the requirement to install a ligtening rod higher than all the cellphone towers. I didn’t experience the slightest slow down from my Sprint Sierra Wireless AirCard even once during the entire time, though. From about a week ago I’m finally getting consistent, fairly good signal strength, indicating that the T-Mobile microwave tower on the corner was finally replaced. I wouldn’t doubt it, if still, none of the companies or their installers have yet realized the requirement to install a lightening rod and there still isn’t one. Does anyone know how I can petition all those companies for a
    job as an installer, or installation supervisor? Or how to best make a case to force all of them to hire me as an installation supervisor? If so, please advise or suggest. Thanks!

    Read more: http://techland.time.com/2011/01/28/how-egypt-cut-off-the-internet/#ixzz1CZIK2RaY

  • http://eautybayomfrayainpay.wordpress.com shellshe

    My sister said that now it will be wwwee.com.
    World wide web except Egypt.

    Thanks for the posting of this article. I’ve not heard much about this but now I want to learn some more about it. Thanks. :)

  • http://metalheadtakesthesquare.wordpress.com metalheadtakesthesquare

    It is such an interesting concept that one could “kill” the internet. It speaks volumes to the role that the web plays in our daily lives. The personification has reached a level that is astounding, so much so that or language now reflects it both consciously and subconsciously. Legislation needs to be well thought out and crafted in this arena to ensure that some very bad things don’t result from the usual shortcomings of rushed, reactionary legislation. I tackle this specific topic in a post called “Liebermann is Gonna Punch the Internet in the Face” on my site. Dangerous times we live in.

  • http://www.kbos2.co.uk/wordpress/ kbos2hm

    if they cut off the internet did that mean they cut phones off as well or do they not have 3g phone access over there you cut the internet off over here id use my phone fialing that id use dial up fialing that again i would use bbs

  • http://sisterearthorganics.wordpress.com Sister Earth Organics

    Unfortunately the US government can do whatever they want under the guise of a “National Emergency”. Thanks for the post.

  • http://windysax.wordpress.com jasperwindysax

    pastilan

  • http://djohnson06.wordpress.com djohnson06

    Why in the world would they do this?? Its not even worth news.

  • http://wheresgodinallofthis.wordpress.com sandyvanasch

    Well, I believe what you said in this article. Remember the country of Burma. They shut down the internet when they had protests in the streets. Citizens have no freedom in Burma. How about the Olympic Games in China. China severely limits and restricts their internet service on an ongoing basis. During the Olympics they were requested by many countries to open the internet without restriction which they did until the games were over.
    Right now, the Obama Administration is working to do the same thing that the Chinese are doing. He has plans on restricting and censoring what all of you who read this are posting on the internet.
    Believe it or not—it can happen in America also!
    Sandy

  • http://spiritfilledpoetry.wordpress.com CommentatorandPoet

    My thanks and appreciation to all on their postings on this subject of the “Kill Switch.” It proves the greatnest of the net in open free communication of subjects that concern us all. In the five years of being a part of the WordPress family, I always found the family as a whole a “class group” in rarely casting “Personal” attacks. Attacks on groups are to be expected, but when they become “personal” toward another WordPress member, they indicate a lack of higher intelligence. An example of this was shythom’s posting, a WordPress member. Of course, when it comes to intelligence, even I know, one does not start a sentence with a small “i” Lol.

  • http://shythom.wordpress.com shythom

    interesting that commentatorandpoet seems to be ignorant of personal attacks – i’ve been a part of the blogging sphere before it was termed as ‘blogging’. the internet is FULL of personal attacks AND group attacks. at least group attacks are based more on, unfortunately, stereotypes and other discrimination.

    i was merely pointing on one person’s irrational logic. lets say i knew that commentatorandpoet was of a certain race. i certainly would not base the entire race one one person’s stupidity. that’s just him/her alone.

    and please… to attack some one for not captilizing ‘i’? that’s all commentatorandpoet’s got??? i’ve seen that many times – how some one tries to win an arguement on the internet, not by making any rebuttal to the stance put against them, but to basically be like a child and say, “yeah… well you don’t even know how to captilize the letter ‘i’ at the beginning of a sentence!” bravo. that is correct, i didn’t. as i continued to do throughout my entire reply.

    if he’s been around on the internet long enough, he’ll at least realize the trend of using small letters with no caps. but honestly – not even sure how that even relates to the topic at hand.

    i say some one was definitely reaching and trying to take away attention away from his narrow-minded statement.

    as mentioned before, how can anyone believe that a right-wing administration would NOT use an ‘off switch’ for the internet if they had the ability to? please! that is beyond laughable.

  • http://shythom.wordpress.com shythom

    and just to add, this is what commentatorandpoet posted on my own blog:

    “Your personal attack against me showed the world what A real jerk you are. You should stick with writing in your own lanquage. That way you can get the sentence structure right. Never seen such poor grammar and sentence structure in my life from one that is suppose to be an adult. Of course, it could be a medical problem with those crossed eyes in your head and those thick glasses Lol.”

    interesting – he bashed me for attacking him personally and yet he felt that he was justified in attacking me on an even more personal level on a very family-oriented blog post.

    first he bashed me for not using any caps (ouch! attacking me where it really hurts!) but then he goes on to make fun of how i look.

    oh… my god. really? that’s how he wishes to win? hitting below the belt? seriously?

    wow – how very classy of him. i didn’t think it would be possible but i now think even less of him from his first idiotic comment here.

  • http://khairulorama.wordpress.com/ khairulorama

    bad idea to cut off the internet. Freedom to speech = freedom to voice out through internet!

  • Secondary School Musings

    The government should have no control over the internet. Although it is usually the government that manages to “give” internet service to citizens, cutting off the internet is clearly a sign of future dictatorship or fascism. In my opinion, freedom of ideas is the most important aspect here. I am Chinese myself and I strongly go against the fact that the Chinese Government banned Youtube, especially after when a Tibetan rebel group put a video up about their views. Is that not Totalitarianism?

blog comments powered by Disqus