A Killer App for Google’s Glasses

What would a "killer app" for Google Glass look like? Tech-industry analyst Tim Bajarin offers his input, then asks for yours

  • Share
  • Read Later
Dan Forbes for TIME

There’s been a lot of talk and excitement about Google Glass. They’ve captured the imagination of the technorati and even garnered feedback from the mainstream media in reports that Google’s computerized eyewear might be barred in certain restaurants and bars. Clearly it’s a fascinating product and concept, though it’s harder to say if it’ll catch on or be successful beyond early adopters who love gadgets.

It’s true that solid use cases for Google Glass could develop in vertical markets, possibly for use in medicine, transportation, public safety, etc. However, at $1,500 it’s hardly a consumer device. The fact that it could take pictures, record video, deliver speech to text and put you into hangouts — even get directions — is interesting, but it would have to do a lot more for consumers to spend that sort of money out of the gate.

That’s how this works, of course: most major technology products start out quite expensive and eventually come down in price over time. Part of getting the price down comes from the early adopters, who help to pay for the R&D costs of the product. And with greater demand, the vendors — in this case Google — get price breaks from component manufacturers, which helps pay down initial equipment and manufacturing costs.

(MORE: Google Glasses Seem Cool, but Voice Control Could Get Out of Hand)

While I don’t think Google’s glasses are headed for consumer-friendly price levels anytime soon, I do think there could be a consumer-oriented app tied to these glasses that might appeal to vertical users as well as a group of consumers that could actually drive high demand for the eyewear, even if the glasses themselves are pricey.

Because of the nature of my work, I’m what you might call a reluctant world traveler. Over 35 years, I’ve traveled close to 4 million miles (6.5 million km) and visited 55 different countries doing work in the tech field. I was born in the U.S., and my first language is English. I took Spanish in high school and on the side have tried to learn French (albeit unsuccessfully). Ironically, my dad was Filipino and my mother was German, and both spoke their respective languages fluently. But I grew up in a time when making sure your kids spoke English well was a priority, so my parents didn’t see the need to teach us Filipino or German.

Like any person traveling to another country where a different language is used, getting around in cities and understanding the various directional signs and printed text is next to impossible. I’ve been to Europe so often that I recognize key words and signs, in part because they use a Roman alphabet. However, when I’m in Japan, China or any other Asian country where they use pictographic images in their writing, I haven’t a clue what they’re trying to tell me. (O.K., that’s not completely true: I have learned to recognize the local signs for “the toilet” in just about every country I visit.)

There’s an amazing app on the iPhone that I use today to decipher words, sentences and even signs in German, French, Spanish or Italian when I’m in countries where these languages are spoken. The app — called Word Lens — uses the iPhone’s camera to translate a foreign language into English in real time. But because of the size of the iPhone’s screen, it only delivers a small portion of a sign or document’s message, and you have to hold the iPhone pretty steady over the words in order to get it to work.

(MORE: Google Glass: An Eyes-On Evaluation)

Now imagine if I were wearing a pair of Google’s glasses, wirelessly tied to an iPhone or Android phone and a mobile version of Google Translate. In theory, I could pick up the local paper in Paris and start reading it as the glasses scanned the words, instantly translating them into English for me. I might be walking down a street and see a sign on the wall of a building and translate it on the spot by simply looking at it. I could go to the subway in Japan and understand signs that offer directions with little more than a glance. Imagine how much it could help any world traveler get the most out of a trip abroad.

Perhaps the biggest adopters of this type of application would be diplomats, politicians and anyone dealing with international relations — including the military. One of my assignments in the past was at the E.U. offices in Geneva, and during my time there I was dealing with documents from dozens of countries that all had to be painstakingly translated. Imagine if I’d had a pair of Google’s glasses back then, taking one of the documents and reading it in real time. It would have changed my workflow dramatically. I know a lot of world and business travelers who I suspect would gladly pay Google’s high early-adopter price for a tool that could do this.

The big question is whether Google’s currently working on such an app. It’s hard for me to believe they wouldn’t already have this in the labs, since marrying Google Glass and Google Translate sounds like a slam dunk. From what I know of the technology, this would be workable today, since mobile processors are getting more powerful and so is the translation software.

I see Google Glass as a great product, but using it for real-time translation would make it revolutionary. The technology that could make this a reality is here already. If Google offers something like this at launch, I’ll be one of the first to buy a pair.

This is my idea for a killer Google Glass app. If you were consulting with Google on the Google Glass project, what killer app would you suggest they make for you?

Bajarin is the president of Creative Strategies Inc., a technology industry analysis and market-intelligence firm in Silicon Valley. He contributes to Big Picture, an opinion column that appears every Monday on TIME Tech.

MORE: Google Hits ‘Glass’ Pedal as Apple Returns to Earth

8 comments
bdesbrisay
bdesbrisay

Very interesting concept. Actually very exciting because this can be done with current technology, but to be able to do so with your sight and automatically instead of pulling out your phone and taking a picture,,, very very cool. Thanks for the article.

johnchavens
johnchavens

Thanks for this piece, and that's a great idea to combine Glass with the translation side of things.  That said, I get confused by articles talking about Glass not getting fully adopted, or how it will be useful for consumers.  As you pointed out, the high price point is temporary, and by definition, all of these killer app ideas could live within the framework of Google/Glass once fairly basic tech issues get out of the way.  To me, those tech fixes are always temporary because either Google or a competitor will see those problems as a business opportunity. 

I say this a lot about AR - whatever the hardware, whether it's 'true AR' (markers, markerless, image-recognition, face recognition), etc, the main thing about it is that Augmented Reality is a new browser.  So, in one sense, to me, asking that the killer App is for Glass is like asking, "what URL would make sense for the Internet?" I'm not saying this to be contrarian or a jerk, mind you.  Just saying that's how big I think AR truly is, and we techie types (I write for Mashable) can get lost in the momentary granularity of the tech/adoption, versus the big picture.  Big picture here is that whether Glass is mainly here to create a paradigm where people (general consumers) get used to this stuff for other companies to come in and dominate (and there are dozens, both with glasses like Vuzix, or contact lenses like APX Labs), or they'll be the dominator, seeing data is inevitable, period.  Anybody is welcome to not like the idea or shun it, but things will change dramatically when we walk around and other people can see our data (face recognition, etc) and RECORD us.  Don't forget - the adoption for these technologies will be much more rapid than even something like cellphones.  With a cellphone, by definition, you need someone else to have one or your phone call is pretty boring.  With Glass, along with the AR/seeing data, you record the world around you.  No matter what Google or anyone else says, or the lame attempts to ask people 'not to video here' etc, the mapping of the world will continue.  We're in for a massive ethical and privacy S*&* storm. 

All that said, my reco is somebody invents the equivalent of a McAffee Virus app for Glass.  Meaning, let people put a virtual shield around themselves that will keep them from being filmed by anybody they don't want to be filmed by.  Or, charge a fee via virtual currency is someone wants to film you.  Work with Starbucks and Square and get a free coffee if you're in somebody's shot and they want you in it versus a floating coffee cup.  

Thanks again for the piece.  But I truly hope we can move beyond the, "will Glass take off and when" conversations to, "this technology is globally available now and will manifest in one way or the other in months - how do we deal with the ethics around this stuff versus the tech?" 

John C. Havens

Founder, The H(app)athon Project. 

a.schwibbe
a.schwibbe

Just I few ideas I think of are imho killer apps for Google Glass:


for Firefighters: project Floorplans or add. information like Exits, Height, Windows, etc. for the building they are in...

for Police: combine with Face-Detection and get data from most wanted data-base, scan number-plates and get information of owner,...

for Paramedics: live hangout with ER to save time when it really matters...

for all of us: Face/People-Detection to warn you when cycling or steering a car crossing your way early enough to stop safely...


NetApex
NetApex

That is a great idea and practically a given for the software.  They have had Google Googles available for quite a while now and it has the ability to do exactly what you are saying (albeit with a click of the camera vs instant live translation)  Think of it like the Chrome addon that switches languages for you.

Jon889
Jon889

You seem to have misunderstood what Google Glass is and does. The problem is Glass is not truely AR, it is more like a HUD in the corner of your eye. It could not overlay the translated words over the foreign words.

To do this would require something more like the Oculus Rift (though I hear it can't display text well at all due to it's low resolution) and a camera attach to the front of it.

Google Glass would be more able to translate signs into audio or short text, but reading a newspaper as if it was written in English, it's not quite there yet.

PaulDirks
PaulDirks

Since I regard the Google glass as nothing more than a massive distraction generator, I'm afraid the only 'killer app' I can think of would be for the camera to be rear mounted and allow you to see behind you as you drive or walk. Anything else is more interference with life than enhancement.


WhiteRootMedia
WhiteRootMedia

That translation app would be great! I would have a Q&A database like Yahoo! Answers and then whenever someone asked Google Glass a question you would hear the top answer from.... lets say Google Answers.

Dusty

White Root Media

http://www.whiterootmedia.com

bdesbrisay
bdesbrisay

@PaulDirks The nice thing about this technology is it can be as distracting or unobtrusive as you want it to be. An iPhone can go into do not disturb mode, and notifications are completely customizable, there is no reason why google glass will not be even more innovative than a phone in this regard.