The Case for Android

An ex-iPhone owner sings the praises of Google's operating system.

  • Share
  • Read Later

Paul Stamatiou switched from an iPhone to an Android phone three months ago. He loves Android. He’s got a lot of company, but I’m not sure if anyone has written as extensive and cogent an argument in favor of Android over iOS:

I set out to write an article about how I feel Android provides unique affordances that create a unique cohesive mobile experience (more on that below) rather than talking openness, features and apps. However, the more time I spent living with Android it became obvious that being able to do anything and suit a variety of needs is a pillar of the Android experience.

Mainly I’m talking about a less restrictive canvas for developers. You can access the file-system, the hardware, use intents to pass data to other apps and services, and much more.

Don’t like the lack of lock screen notifications? Install DashClock (example) or NiLS. Want to customize the LED color or each type of notification? Light Flow is just the ticket. I predict many more lock screen notification apps will emerge soon; Android 4.3 brings needed notification APIs (current lock screen solutions hackily register as an accessibility service). For example, you can bring Moto X style notifications that light up your screen when notifications arrive with ActiveNotifications.

I don’t agree with Stamatiou’s conclusion that Android is definitively better than iOS. (To me, it’s more that both platforms are excellent choices for a lot of folks, but neither is the right one for everybody.) There are certain places where my take is the opposite of his, such as his contention that Android’s universal back button is one of the best things about the operating system. (It drives me nuts, since its behavior varies from app to app.) There are also instances where Android’s advantages seem less striking to me than he suggests. (He rightly lavishes praise on Google Now, but it’s also available for iOS.)

And note that he’s been using “Pure Google” phones running an unaltered version of Android – a scenario in which the software does indeed shine, but one which is anything but typical.

Still, he makes his case well. If you like Android, show this piece to your pals to help explain why. If you prefer iOS but have an open mind, you should also pay attention. And if you’re uncommitted and trying to decide what your next smartphone should run, it’s a must read.


 every android phone you use OUGHT have

PDroid framework

applied to recover USER CONTROL of app permissions and data

  • root
  • remove GAPPS -- google apps chew through battery; Network Location "service" cannot be disabled; see also NOGAPPS Project
  • install miui rom -- best gain: call filtering
  • apply PDroid framework
  • install Waze -- no doubt best navigation on android
  • install Xabber -- XMPP texting, $0, completely replaces costly slow sms texting
  • buy Light Flow -- put color led to good use
  • buy Tasker
  • contacts via LDAP or outlook dot com
  • calendar via outlook dot com
  • install Llama
  • install AdAway -- but NEVER install malware (those apps showing web ads while contrafactually claiming to be free; adware is not-free; see also "privacy rape")
  • buy GroundWire -- pair with anveo for serious calling or callcentric for casual $0 SIP to SIP calling.  
  • buy DMFS Contact Editor PRO -- Mature people have more than one contact phone number.
  • install Glympse
  • install F-droid


(I carry both android phone and iphone; I'm no fanboi)



When it comes to successful products folks will often hear me talk about "Critical Mass".

As most of you recall, for a long time Apple was restricted to AT&T. If Apple had been able to make the move to Verizon just six months earlier Android phone may never have been able to grab the critical mass they needed for the  market. For a long time the commercials were true. AT&T did not have the nationwide coverage that Verizon did. At the time when I made my first powerful smart phone purchase, an iPhone was not an option. The locations I used the most were areas famous for dropped AT&T calls.

If not for the failure of AT&T and/or the success of Version, many more iPhones would have been sold and Android may never have obtained the foothold on the market.

Bill Pytlovany

Read more: