Adobe’s $10-per-Month Photoshop Subscription Warrants a Cautious High Five

The new Photoshop Photography Program offers a 50% single-app discount -- and perks besides -- to Photoshop CC holdouts.

  • Share
  • Read Later
Adobe

In May, Adobe upended its business model and upset broad swathes of its install base by shifting, full steam ahead, to a subscription-only model for its creative suite of tools, including Photoshop, Illustrator and InDesign. That subscription model had been around since 2011, but it was optional: Until this spring, Adobe still offered a boxed product you could pay for up front and use as long as you liked.

Adobe’s design tools have never been downmarket price-wise, but users accustomed to working with just one of those tools — Photoshop, say, but not, Illustrator; or Audition but not Premiere Pro — were able to work around paying the full suite pricing by purchasing a la carte, even if they paid more on a per-product basis (it’s always been cheaper to pay the suite price if you use everything it offers and keep up with upgrades). My brother, who occasionally does audio engineering work and who was using Audition before Adobe snatched it from Syntrillium (where it was known as Cool Edit Pro) a decade ago, was mortified to learn that in order to have access to the latest version of just that one program, he’d have to pay for all the others in perpetuity.

Audition CS6 standalone, the last boxed version, cost $349 full price (the upgrade pricing ranged from $75 to $149, version depending, and there was no educational pricing — Adobe yanked it from most of its products last year). By comparison, an Audition subscription, pre-Creative Cloud, ran $19.95 a month if you signed up for a year, or $29.95 a month if you went month-to-month. Assuming you signed up for the annual package, you’d pay about $240 a year. But that’s fairly steep for a single piece of software that only went through six version transitions in 10 years.

Thus Creative Cloud, which for a few dollars more if you already owned a version of Creative Suite, let you have access to virtually everything Adobe makes for $29.99 a month, or about $360 a year. If you weren’t already a Creative Suite owner, the monthly fee leapt to $49.99, or $600 a year, and the 40% discount for prior Creative Suite owners disappears after December 3, 2013.

But any way you run those numbers, you wind up paying more on balance than you would have under Adobe’s boxed product pricing plans (assuming you were keeping up with upgrades, anyway, and note I’m talking about upgrade pricing, not full pricing, where in at least some instances Creative Cloud comes off looking a little more attractive). Whether you feel like the value’s offset any by the extras Adobe packs into Creative Cloud — instant upgrades, saving to the cloud, enhanced sharing and so forth — depends on how much you value such things.

Niche products like Audition aside, Adobe’s most popular tool remains Photoshop. When Adobe tried to drag Photoshop users into its subscription model, including me, many balked (including me). I chose to respectfully part ways with the company and shifted to Pixelmator, a prosumer photo-tweaking tool (albeit Mac-only) that sells for $14.99 on the Mac App Store.

Yesterday, during its keynote at Photoshop World in Las Vegas, Adobe attempted to ameliorate some of that photography-specific backlash, unveiling something it’s dubbed a Photoshop Photography Program, aimed at Photoshoppers who don’t need the Creative Cloud smorgasbord, and who weren’t persuaded by the single-app pricing options introduced last month.

With PPP, if you own any version of Photoshop from CS3 forward, you pay just $9.99 a month to access Photoshop CC, Lightroom 5, Behance ProSite membership (an online pro-photo showcase tool) and 20GB of cloud storage. You have to sign up by December 31, 2013 to get that price, but if you do, Adobe says that’s what you’ll pay going forward, with no post-introductory hikes down the road.

Is $120 a year low enough to pry open your wallet? It’s still about $100 too expensive for mine, but then I’m not even a proper amateur photographer (my idea of professional camera work involves buying a high-end point-and-shoot and leaving the settings dial on “auto”). I use Pixelmator to resize, transform, or touch up photos for work or when I’m scanning in CD booklet info for my music collection, and that’s about it. I’ve never used but a fraction of what a professional tool like Photoshop offers.

How much will Adobe’s PPP run after the offer date passes? Adobe isn’t saying, but it seems logical to assume it’ll climb back to Adobe’s standard single-app Creative Cloud $29.99 per month pricing.

8 comments
BillSchiffbauer
BillSchiffbauer

Of course the cloud assumes a person is always able to be on line.

Not true so no on line, no access.  Bad idea from my viewpoint.

DanCentury
DanCentury

I'm thinking it's worth it. I'm been using Pixelmator for years, but side by side it can't compare to Photoshops. Pixelmator is fantastic for basics (cropping, resizing, basic filter work), but it can't compare in terms of performance, speed, and some basic tasks like creating a drop shadow.

scottyisgaga
scottyisgaga

I don't need Adobe's horrible customer service when something goes wrong with my charges on my credit card. I heard cancelling is almost impossible. Adobe is toast, and they know it. The fact that they extended the CS3 upgrade deadline about 10 times says so. Hopefully Apple buys up the good parts when they sell off the company.

elhajj33
elhajj33

For occasional/hobby use pixelmator is a good choice, so is using Lightroom and photoshop elements.  But, if you're someone who was paying $199 every 18months (on average) for photoshop + another $75 for lightroom, then the new program makes sense.  You pay roughly ~$180 every 18 months for the two tools.

The worry is when will Adobe change the price?  Adobe was pretty adamant that they wouldn't, but once you buy in, who knows...  Then again, worst case scenario is you downgrade back to what you had.  

I'm going to take the plunge.  I can always go back to CS6 if i need to and Adobe says this still plan on selling LR as a separate product.  I wish there was a way to stop paying at some point and stay with the features you paid up until that point in time.

I wrote up some some additional thoughts on this (along with the catches to the deal) on my blog: http://goo.gl/skPqel